Saturday, February 04, 2006

Degreed Idiot Embarrasses Species.


"Of course Hitler is evil, but he has tenure. So sadly, we can do nothing but respectfully disagree with him.”

-- quote from Chancellor Winston Churchill…from my non-existent novel, "The Man in the High Ivory Tower" (title poached from Phillip K. Dick) about an alternate reality where university presidents govern the free world.

This story answers the age old question: “Can a kooky Northwestern University professor find true polyamorous happiness in the clammy arms of Iranian fundy lunatics?”

Sure, as long as they have rabid antisemitism to keep their love strong and their cloven hooves warm at night.

In fact, they have their own song (sung to the tune these song from “The Mary Tyler Moore Show” -- "Love Is All Around" -- written and sung by Sonny Curtis)

1…2…3…

Who can turn Tehran on with his bile?
Who can take a wretched lie, and try to make seem much less vile?

Well it's you bitch, and we all know it
NU's Nazi flake, and every time you speak up you show it.

Your lies fly all around, but sinecure saves you.
’Cause Hitler’s favorite clown has tenure at NU.

Where do you get the fucking gall?
Where do you get the fucking gall?

Here’s the appalling story.
NU professor backs denial of Holocaust by Iran chief
Jewish leaders fear support could add credibility to view

By Jodi S. Cohen
Tribune higher education reporter

February 4, 2006

A Northwestern University professor known for denying the Holocaust happened has publicly sided with Iran's hard-line president, who has been on a campaign against Israel.

Engineering professor Arthur Butz said Friday that he agrees with Iranian President Mahmoud Ahmadinejad's remarks calling the Holocaust a "myth." Butz said his comments supporting the president recently were published by the English-language Tehran Times and Iran's semi-official Mehr news agency.

Butz, a tenured professor whose views have been known in the United States for years, is being promoted by Iranian news sources as one of the world scholars who support Ahmadinejad's views on the Holocaust.

"I congratulate him on becoming the first head of state to speak out clearly on these issues and regret only that it was not a Western head of state," Butz said in a Mehr news report. He posted the same comments on his Northwestern-provided Web site.


"I continue to maintain those three theses, which have become core features of what is called `Holocaust revisionism.' Apart from some nuances of wording, the three theses were repeated by President Ahmadinejad. Therefore, there can be no question that I endorse his remarks in those respects," Butz wrote.

Since 1996, Butz has posted his views about the Holocaust on his Northwestern-affiliated Web site, including information from his 1976 book "The Hoax of the 20th Century: The Case Against the Presumed Extermination of European Jewry."

Northwestern University spokesman Al Cubbage emphasized that the university does not agree with Butz.

"As certainly has been made clear on many occasions, Northwestern University as an institution obviously does not endorse or agree with the personal opinions of professor Butz," Cubbage said. "At the same time, however, the university does believe that its faculty members are entitled to express their own personal opinions."


It doesn’t surprise me that some affectless, ethical abend of an engineer would seize on Holocaust denial as a freak cause/obsession/road-to-contrarian-infamy. It seems to be a disease of a certain subspecies of that breed. They live with a vital chunk missing from their Edward Teller souls. A hole blown out where their humanity should be, and the cavity topped off with that particular and polluted pitchblend that magnetizes them in some horrible way, luring them inexorably towards the ferrous pleasures of fascism.

No, what revolted me was the response from Northwestern. To repeat:
"As certainly has been made clear on many occasions, Northwestern University as an institution obviously does not endorse or agree with the personal opinions of professor Butz," Cubbage said. "At the same time, however, the university does believe that its faculty members are entitled to express their own personal opinions."


The existence and extent of the Holocaust is not a matter of opinion, personal or otherwise.

And some wannabe goose-stepper – tenured or not – doesn’t get to hide behind “opinion” any more that you or I get to assert that the freezing point of water or the distance from the Sun to the Earth are matters subject to our private belief systems.

If this feep wants to go Full Metal Goebbels and opine that the Nazis were heroes, and mass murder was a noble act, fine. As vomitous as it is, that would qualify as a “personal opinion”.

But existence of the Holocaust is non-negotiable.

Which is why the tepid, boneless response from NU makes me sick. These are the kind of people I know, and this summarizes to a tee exactly what has gone wrong in the “tolerance gone wild" culture of the academy. A mealy-mouthed response to Butz’s comments from NU was not only sadly predictable and reflexive, but also entirely unnecessary and self-defeating.

What they needed to say was something like...

“The reality of Holocaust -- both as moral catastrophe and historical fact -- is beyond debate and Mr. Butz’s insane comments are an insult to intelligent humans everywhere. Mr. Butz’s free speech rights are, of course, respected, and since he somehow managed to snag a tenured position here, it is true that we can’t fire him unless he fondles a coed.

However it is also true that we wouldn't exactly be disappointed if Mr. Butz’s hair caught fire…and he chose to try to douse the flames with a shotgun.

Or a coed.”


Straightforward and unambiguous.

And yet with 100 PhDs-per-square-yard, somehow Northwestern can’t form their collective mouths to denounce this ass and, more importantly, the basis of his despicable assertion in language that is simple, clear and muscular.

12 comments:

Anonymous said...

Despite their sharing of a profession, I doubt Chief Engineer Scott would drink with Butz The Putz.

Anonymous said...

Ahh, the refreshing moral clarity of a diamond-bladed scalpel, gentling parting the waters between fact and opinion, banishing obsfucation.

Anonymous said...

ID isn't anywhere near the hot-button issue that Holocaust denial is, but IIRC Lehigh University has been pretty vigorous in denying any connection with Prof. Behe's views. What's NU's problem?

Anonymous said...

My daughter is an undergrade at NU. And Jewish. Perhaps I'll send a note to the administration.

--gravie

driftglass said...

Anonymous,
It is the "we agree to disagree" flavor of their statement that is the problem. There is no disgreement. Like people who oppose teaching evolution, or insist that there is no such thing as global warming, people who deny the Holocaust have a very particular agenda and Step #1 of the plan is always to create the illusion that there is some kind of controversy to be debated.

There is no controversy, and for an institution as well-funded and powerful as NU to dodge behind the idea that this is a matter of "opinion" is intolerable.

I realize that they're run mostly by conflict-averse fraidy cats, but Universities are supposed to be in the business of teaching truth and critical thinking skills.

It says so right on the letterhead.

And if it were actually true, they would step up to their responsible for calling people like Butz out on his hateful nonsense.

Anonymous said...

I sure hope your knees didn't hurt you or anyone in the vicinity. Good grief, take a look at what you are saying.

I really enjoy your writing and views but this is outrageous. If someone has an opinion contrary to yours he has to be silenced. Welcome to cheney's world.

Your truth and someone's else's truth can be and often are different.

If academics have to seek official approval before posting their writings we would be.....well where you would have us.

How is your rant different from the Muslim leaders who asked for an apology from Denmark re the cartoons published of the prophet Mohammed?

Freedom of speech, what an interesting concept.

Anonymous said...

SteeleyDan - I don't see where DG is requesting Butz-hed to be silenced or censored, but thanks for the spin. The wussy response from NU in regards to Butz-hed's delusionary revisionism is emblematic of Ivorytowers anywhere. Fuck that - keep the schmuck on the payroll, but denounce his ass and hold him to task - don't just sqibble "we agree to disagree". Fuckin' take the gloves off and spank the bastard, require him to sabbatical it out = ie "show us the money bitch" with some research and hard facts or face a reduction in funding, or something. Put the spotlight on the fucker and make his monkey ass dance.


It's a fine line between Assoc Pr. and tenure - I don't expect those subject to the whims of Administrative Review to offer their necks for chopping. I only wish for this neonaszti's fellow tenured-cogitors (in name only) to speak their minds so freely as well. Alas, tis a mercenary job at best.

-skunq

roxtar said...

Whadda ya wanna bet that this assclown is related to the one, the only former Nixon/Ford Agriculture Secretary Earl Butz?

You remember Earl:

"Butz allegedy uttered the following comment while on board Air Force One during Ford's 1976 re-election campaign, "I'll tell you what the coloreds want. It's three things: first, a tight pussy; second, loose shoes; and third, a warm place to shit." American newspapers and news magazines wanted to cover this, especially after the resulting scandal resulted in his firing, but found it impossible to print a statement so racist and obscene. Some paraphrased, saying for example that Butz had commented on the desire of black Americans to have "good sex, comfortable shoes, and a warm place to go the bathroom." Others stated that he had said something too obscene to print, and invited their readers to contact the editors if they wanted more information. The negative publicity from the statement forced Butz to resign from his Cabinet post on October 4, 1976." (Excerpt from Wikipedia.)

triozyg said...

Not opinions:

Columbus arrived in N. America in 1492
The allies won WWII
Millions of Jews were put to death in Nazi death camps
George Bush is president of the US

Anonymous said...

Wow, Drifty, you really got me with that. I am furiously supportive of free speech, and I was initially concerned where you were going with this post. But you nailed it with the suggested NU response. If only we lived in a world where such things would happen.

Anonymous said...

Hey, I 110% agree with the last few comments. This blog has great opinions and this is why I continue to visit, thanks! Ms. Epson ink cartridges

Anonymous said...

Bloggers

Looking for home contractor web sites at http://doityourselfpro.com/. Well I recomend This Site.