Blue Gal and I were late for breakfast.
Or, rather, later than we usually were when traveling. We enjoyed the luxury of a little more sleep without alarms or deadlines, then got up and slowly climbed into the day. Which is how we happened to be almost the only people in the Burlington, Iowa Fairfield Inn's open-area breakfast buffet and dining room. It was just us and the woman who was getting ready to wipe down the tables and vacuum the floor after we left. We'll call her Ms. B.
More about her later.
Because of the relative tardiness of our arrival, most of the eggs and taters were gone, but what was left was adequate. The bacon was the thinnest sliced I'd ever seen. Like mica, or that spiderweb of crystals that can form at the edge of a pond during a cold snap -- a suggestion of bacon written on the wind. CNN was on the large, wall-mounted teevee, and because of our relative tardiness, we got there just in time to see that Fareed Zakaria's guest on his GPS show was Mr. David Brooks, now of The Atlantic.
As I pumped some of the coffee out of the coffee Airpot samovar labeled "BOLD" (it wasn't), that dispenses hot beverages at motels these days, I started to laugh at our surreal timing.
Minutes earlier we'd been in our room, looking up the lineup of the big four Sunday shows and talking about how over and done with that whole format had become. One Democrat. One or two Republicans. A panel of pundits jerking each other off. All of them teetering between inconsequential and completely irrelevant. A dying carnival with rusting rides and threadbare acts playing smaller and smaller venues and drawing ever fewer and older customers.
We hadn't even bothered to check to see what was on offer with Zakaria because he's not even a dying carnival: he's a dying sideshow act at a dying carnival.
So as I attended to my not-really-very-BOLD coffee, I laughed, and Ms. B asked what I was laughing at.
"Nothing really," I said, moving on to filling a little plastic cup with cranberry juice. "Private joke between my wife and I."
"The guy on TV," my wife offered. "My husband really doesn't like him."
So it must have been a mystery to Ms. B. why we kept the TV tuned to CNN and turned the volume up a few ticks so that it was audible. Ms. B. must have also thought our little exchange meant that we were open to chat with her. Turned out that we were, but more about that later.
As we watched, Zakaria and Brooks managed to masticate just about every played-out legacy media cliché, and spit it back and forth into each other's mouths, like baby birds playing with their food.
For example, did you know that, as unpopular as Republicans are...Democrats are very nearly as unpopular? It's true! And almost as many people who identify as either Republicans or Democrats now call themselves ...independents? Didja know that? Well didja?
No mention of the 1986 foundational study, "The Myth of the Independent Voter", which found that most "independent leaners" vote much like ordinary partisans.
No mention of the 1992 book, which expanded on that study.
No mention of the 2019 Pew Research Center study that found the same thing. Most "independents" aren't independent. That while 38% of Americans described themselves as independents, most of those independents leaned toward either the Democratic or Republican Party. And fewer than 10% of the entire public were genuinely independent, meaning they expressed no partisan leaning.
No mention of Pew's July 14, 2026 "Party Affiliation Fact Sheet," which found the same thing. That while 44% of American adults identify as independent or something else, approximately 77% of self-described independents lean toward one of the two parties. So less than a quarter of people who call themselves independent actually are. Which, once again, comes to around 10%.
No mention of the toxic effect that 40 years of relentless, daily Both Siderism from the legacy media might have had on the public perception that both parties are equally terrible, when they are manifestly and obviously different. No mention that one of the legacy media's most infamous and unrelenting purveyors of that poisonous "Both Sides Do It" lie was David Brooks, who, at the moment, was sitting right across the table from Zakaria.
None of that was mentioned at all. Just that, even though everyone knows that both parties are so terrible that a third of the country say a pox on both your houses and claim to be independents, how do you explain the absolute drubbing that Republicans took during the midterms?
As I said, it was a feast of Beltway platitudes passed back and forth on a fairly niche program that caters to the consultant and Davos crowd, complete with analysis from Axios on the quality of Democratic ads.
Zakaria: Donald Trump really did a kind of hostile takeover of the Republican Party.
To repeat myself for the hundredth time, no, no, and no. In 2016, Republican voters were offered 15 different flavors of same-old-same-old, and Donald Trump. Trump, you will recall, swept the field with relative ease and then went on to lose the popular vote in 2016, but win in the Electoral College.
Then Republican voters nominated him again in 2020, and voted for him again in the tens of millions.
Then, after Trump led an insurrection against the United States government and was impeached for it but not removed because Mitch McConnell wished it to be so, Republican voters nominated Trump for a third time and elected him president for a second time.
That, by definition, is not a hostile takeover. That is, in fact, the opposite of a hostile takeover.
That was the bigots and imbeciles of the Republican base finally getting what they'd been demanding for decades. It only seems like a hostile takeover to the cosseted elitists like Zakaria and Brooks, who never bothered to leave their safe media spaces long enough to discover what the Republican base was really like, or what it really wanted.
Of course, since those are the same cosseted elites who dominated the Sunday Shows and the op-ed pages, the myth of the "hostile takeover" became the received wisdom of the punditocracy.
For the record, as these goofs were talking, I was not transcribing them word-for-word. I just jotted down the highlights while chuckling through my eggs and taters and pulled the transcript off of YouTube later on.
Brooks: Yeah, I thought the day after the election, Ron DeSantis, the governor of Florida, said this has been for the Republican Party a near-extinction event. I think he's not wrong. As you said, we all had an image of the Reagan Republican Party. It was a free trade party. It was pretty open on immigration...
Yadda, yadda, yadda.
Brooks: ... and Donald Trump comes and suddenly it's the party of tariffs, of protectionism, of uh of government takeover of industries. Like, it's crazy what's been happening. And then suddenly, boom. I think that's gone. Uh, I think not only is the era of Trumpism gone there. I think we've passed peak populism at least in the United States.
Zakaria: So you think this is a rejection not just of Trump but of MAGA.
Brooks: This year, the Democrats won the House by 14 percentage points. That's twice as big as what we thought was the biggest shakeup midterm setback. That is massive.
And
Brooks: The Republicans are thinking -- a lot of them that I've spoken to the last couple of days -- they're not terribly unhappy. They're like, "Well, we need to change. We deserve this. We ran out that string. We need to change." The problem is, intellectually, they stood for one thing under Reagan. They stood for the opposite under Trump. What do they stand for now?
No, the problem is, there's no reason to believe a fucking word of it. No reason to believe Brooks has any insight into anything. No reason to believe that these anonymous "Republicans" he claims to have talked to exist at all. And especially no reason to believe that the engine of the Republican Party -- its base of bigots and imbeciles -- has learned any lesson at all.
Zakaria: And isn't the bigger problem the base of the party is now it's essentially a kind of white working class somewhat resentful of a lot of the changes that have happened in America and they have... they ... you know it seems like they've lost some of that old... so they've lost the old coalition. What's the new coalition?
"Now"? Seriously? The GOP has been the party of angry white guys at least since Reagan. Which, again, is something the savvy pundits dare not admit.
Brooks: And so what they have to do is they have to marry the best of the old with the best of the new and create a synthesis. Donald Trump was a zero-sum guy. And so I think the Republican Party has to do is be the party of growth, the party of growth and aspiration. We're going to help you rise and succeed.
This feels exactly like a meeting I've had, in one form or another, dozens of times at various failing organizations. This kind of "Someone really oughta come up with vision" senior management powwow, which they have convened because they no longer have any idea what they should be doing or why they should be doing it.
Brooks: Second, Donald Trump had a certain view of power which was an ill liberal concentration of power. The Republicans have to fix that, right? They, they have to have a different conception of power.
This is just pathetic. Also, somebody seems to have forgotten all about his old pal Dick Cheney and his obsession with the Unitary Executive theory?
Brooks then runs through the rest of his laundry list of things Republicans should do, and which they have absolutely no intention of doing.
On the TV, Zakaria is on to his second topic: What about Trump? And in the Fairfield Inn breakfast area, we can feel Ms. B. hovering.
But before we get to Ms. B., let's give Mr. Brooks a little more rope.
When asked about Trump, Brooks shrugs and acknowledges that...
Brooks: When I talk about the future of the Republican Party that there's always a two-year parenthesis there. I just don't think there's going be much change. They're going to be inclined to oppose what other Democrats do. They'll cry socialist, stuff like that."
So for two years, every Republican Brooks knows and with whom he has had a long, insider relationship will go right on being a craven, bootlicking coward.
Brooks: I've known these Republicans all this time who were, like, when I would watch them down the hall, especially in the Trump first term, would look at me like ... body language [imagine cringing, wincing body language here]. They would see me, and they're like -- cuz they knew I was judging them about their fealty to Trump... But now they're going to break a little out of their shell.
Shell? What shell? What the fuck are you talking about? These friends of yours you've known for all these years? They're cowards, Mr. Brooks, not cicadas, and this is not a chrysalis from which one slowly emerges once the coast is clear. They're traitors to their offices and their country. They're Trump's sniveling collaborators. Democracy's backstabbers. This is who they are. What they are.
But ever the professional delusional, Brooks holds out hope that they will somehow shamble into action by doing...what exactly? Offering to give Democrats veto-proof majorities on their first five bills, no questions asked? Resurrecting Barry Goldwater and marching with his mortal remains up to the Ballroom to tell the Trump it's time to go?
Of course not.
Instead, Brooks handwaves in the general direction of Washington, D.C. and predicts that they will "fix Congress" in some unspecified way.
And then, a year from now...
Brooks: ...once the election gets going...um then we can have new ideas. But if I'm Ron DeSantis or whoever, I'm thinking, okay, what are the new ideas here? How do I become new? How do I become original? Because people are going to want some freshness. I think JD Vance's political career is over personally. Uh, I just think he's tarred.
So who exactly will this dispenser of fresh ideas be? From which Republican cesspool will they arise untarnished?
Brooks has no idea.
Brooks: The person who's the future face of the Republican Party is already out there, but they're not famous yet. That's my basic view. There's somebody out there who is. And I think the one thing that person has to have is, uh moral credibility. Uh, and so I think there's somebody out there who can speak in a way that's morally credible.
Imagine me laughing hard enough at this point that if there were a crowd around, I'd be attracting an immodest amount of attention.
Brooks: That, okay, the corruption stuff, you don't have to like coastal elites to know that corruption is bad, the lying is bad.
The base of your former party lives on lies, Mr. Brooks. It's their bread and butter and Metamucil. Without constant, reassuring lies, the Republican Party would cease to exist, and if the usual sources of feeding that addiction stop doing so, all that does is create a marketing opportunity for even bigger and more pernicious liars.
Brooks: And so somebody out there who can speak from the...the kind of faith that... that Talerico now speaks. How the heck did the Democrats get ownership over that?
Because the reeking corpse of Jerry Falwell and his white Christian nationalist imitators became the prophets of the only God your bigoted, rage-drunk base wanted to worship. Because they wanted no part of the God of Matthew 25. And do you remember who invited all of those bigots into the GOP in the first place? It was Richard Nixon. And do you remember who campaigned directly into those bigots' grievances and who brought scum like Falwell into the inner circles of Republican power? It was your hero, St. Ronald Reagan.
Now watch carefully as Brooks palms this card.
Brooks: And in, like, 1976, we were sick of Watergate. We felt stained. And we went to [music] Jimmy Carter. And nobody two years before was thinking, you know, that Jimmy Carter guy is probably gonna be the next president. Nobody was thinking that. Uh, and so I think there's somebody out there who can speak in a way that's morally credible.
Fun Fact: David Brooks was all of 15 in 1976, so I dunno where all this "we" nonsense is coming from.
But more to the point, if we're talking about how the Republican Party purges itself of its corruption and depravity, then dragging Jimmy Carter into it as a historical parallel is a perfect example of Brooks' hilarious cluelessness. Yes, after Nixon and Watergate the country was revolted, but the country didn't react by going on a snipe hunt for a morally credible Republican. Hell, they had Republican Jerry Ford already in the White House, sitting right there, but the country told him to fuck off and elected a Democratic peanut farmer instead.
Brooks: ...[The] Republican Party has to recapture Christianity. Uh, and so some person who has moral integrity outside of politics.
Very much like good ol' Joey Tabula Rasa 23 years ago, Brooks will never hesitate to conjure imaginary characters out of thin air and then inflate them with his own list of things that he wished were true.
Wait a minute? You don't know about Joey Tabula Rasa? Or the totally non-racist Tea Party Brooks claimed to have spotted one afternoon in a park in D.C.? Or the imaginary conservative renaissance that's always just around the corner that Brooks has been predicting every few months for the last 25 years? Or the great Rubio surge that was definitely going to save the Republican Party from both Ted Cruz and Donald Trump?
Yeah, Brooks does this shit all the time. And the reason I can rattle off four or eight or two-dozen examples off the top of my head is that I've been documenting Brooks' atrocities -- and how effortlessly he gets away with them -- for more than 20 years.
And the reason he keeps getting away with it is, ironically, the same reason Trump kept getting away with all the lies he tells: because the target audiences for their respective lies desperately want those lies to be true and are willing to pay the person who lies to them.
Brooks: I'm a conservative of a kind that used to be very popular. So my two heroes are Edmund Burke...[and] Alexander Hamilton.
No, Brooks is a conservative of a kind that used to be very popular... among the members of the small, privileged, insulated bubble where Brooks plied his trade for the past 40 years. His brand of Conservatism is not now and never had been the ideological orientation of the base of the Republican Party -- an entity composed of tens of millions of Americans and with whom Brooks -- and everyone in Brooks' social class -- is entirely unfamiliar, even though their professional status and livelihoods depend entirely on which way the base jumps.
And speaking of the Republican base, most of whom have never heard of Edmund Burke or Alexander Hamilton, this is where Ms. B. re-enters the chat.
Ms. B. appeared to have led a hard life. She was probably in her late 40s or early 50s, although she looked older and more worn down. Her car, parked in the sparsely populated lot, had also clearly seen better days: a beater held together with duct tape and bungee cords.
But there she was, on the job, working hard, which was admirable.
Earlier she'd asked us what brought us to town, and I told her that I loved the place because it held very fond memories of my grandparents, my aunt and cousins. I mentioned my grandparents' old address, and that my dad had met my mother here when he was teaching at the local high school, which I'd noticed was being rehabbed into affordable housing for seniors, and wasn't that a good thing.
That apparently marked us as local enough to be trusted with Ms. B.'s terrible secret.
As we were sipping the last of our coffee, from behind us Ms. B. announced, "They're shutting our electricity off."
Tantalizing, no?
We asked if she meant the motel? Like they had to shut off the power to do some maintenance? Silently, we both wondered if she meant the local utility company was going to shut off her power for non-payment or something. That sort of thing happens all the time
No, not the motel.
You mean the whole town?
No. The whole country.
Really? The whole country.
Yes. They're gonna shut the whole country down. We'll be without electricity for 90 days. Can you imagine? With winter coming on?
We didn't ask, but the word "They" hung in the air ominously. "They" were always up to something, weren't they? When they weren't busy stealing elections, they were doing trans surgery on your kid at grade school, or eating the pets, or trying to kill us with death panels.
I said that I'd better get busy splitting more firewood to keep us warm.
Ms. B. nodded and said she knew someone who heated their whole house with firewood. Didn't need electricity at all.
That's smart planning.
Blue Gal said that this sounded pretty bad.
Ms. B. nodded and said that "they're" going to ship all "that stuff" overseas.
I said that I knew there were millions of people out there with generators, and that maybe we should get one, and hopefully we could all get through this.
"So where did you hear about this?" Blue Gal asked gently.
"From my boyfriend's mother," Ms. B said.
Ah. And where did she hear about it? Was it on the news?
Ms. B. said they don't watch the news. The news lies all the time, so she hasn't watched the news for about 13 years.
Oh. Well, where did your boyfriend's mother hear about it?
From YouTube.
Ah.
"Well you know the nice thing about YouTube," I said, "is it's free. I bought a copy of The Hawk Eye ("Iowa's Oldest Paper") yesterday, and it cost me $4.50."
"I remember when it only cost fifty cents!" Ms. B said.
"Same thing with our local paper back home," I said. "Crazy, right? And it barely even mentions local news. It's supposed to be the capital city newspaper, but some of us call it 'The Rockford Files' because we get way more news from 200 miles away in Rockford than we get in Springfield."
To Blue Gal I said, "But you know the problem with YouTube, right?"
"The ads," she said. "So many ads."
We all nodded in agreement that YouTube has too many ads.
"Especially during campaign season," Blue Gal added.
We all nodded in agreement that it's even worse during campaign season.
Blue Gal told about Dorothy Turner, who was running for re-election as our state senator, and appeared to have bought out 90% of all YouTube advertising for our area. It was suffocating and eventually got to be a joke that YouTube was now the Dorothy Turner channel, which was interrupted now and then with stuff you actually wanted to watch.
"I read she spent something like 1.8 million dollars on that campaign," I said.
"Imagine how much good could have been done with that money," Blue Gal said.
We all shook our heads disapprovingly.
Then we bid Ms. B. farewell.
And that, Mr. Brooks, is the Republican base.

No comments:
Post a Comment