Thursday, February 25, 2021

Bylines Like Mardi Gras Beads

I continue to be amused on-the-cheap by how the mainstream media continues to shower people with opinion-having gigs whose sole qualification for the job is that they have spent their entire adult lives being dead wrong about the most consequential political story of their lives...which is now the subject about which they are being paid to opine/

For example, today we find Tom Nichols in the pages of The Atlantic, sitting shiva for his Republican Party:

The Republican Party Is Now in Its End Stages

The GOP has become, in form if not in content, the Communist Party of the Soviet Union of the late 1970s.

Ol' Tom then treats readers to the eighth longest metaphor in modern American letters by devoting [checks notes] 740 paragraphs to the history of the Communist Party before getting around to...

This should all sound familiar.

The Republican Party has, for years...

You know what? It does sound familiar.  

In fact, it sounds exactly like what OG Liberal blogger Digby was writing way back in 2006 when she tweaked the old Bolshevik adage about Communism to draw attention to the almost Stalinist way in which modern Conservatism was making and unmaking its heroes, villains and unpersons based on the needs of the moment:

Conservatism cannot fail, it can only be failed. (And a conservative can only fail because he is too liberal.)... In this I actually envy the right. When they fail, as everyone inevitably does at times, they don't lose their faith. Indeed, failure actually reinforces it... The Republicans are smart enough to rid themselves of failure by always being able to convince themselves that the failure had nothing to do with their belief system.

And OG Liberal biographer Rick Perlstein claims that he came up with this apt little epigram even earlier.

Point being that during all those years that Tom Nichols spent lying to himself about his Party of Reagan, there were plenty of voices on the Left clearly and cogently describing exactly what trajectory the GOP was on, and what kind of horrors awaited all of us if it wasn't stopped.  

Or. to misquote Godfather II (as one does), the Republican Party has been dying from the same heart attack for the last forty years.  

And yet Tom Nichols not only spent those years in complete denial about it, but is very, very sensitive on the subject and gets super pissed when anyone brings it up.  So how did it come to be that ol' Tom was the one whose political expertise The Atlantic chose to tap to write 822 paragraphs on the fall of Communism, sandwiched between a handful of words about the Republican Party?  Words that read remarkably like what Liberal blogger were writing about the Right almost exactly to-the-day 15 years ago?

Since no one who runs in those circles is likely to answer basic questions like these anytime soon, I doubt we'll ever find out exactly why this particular department of the wingnut welfare program just goes mindlessly on.  On the other hand, since no one will explain or even acknowledge that it is deeply warped to hire people to write about a subject about which they have been so flagrantly wrong for so long, until proven otherwise we should assume that the motives involved are dark, vile and salacious.  


Remember When I Told You To Burn The Lifeboats?


3 comments:

namekarB said...

I remember my grandpappy praising President Theodore Roosevelt,then leader of the Republican Party, for being a "true" conservative for all his "conservation" work.

Unknown said...

"...since no one will explain or even acknowledge that it is deeply warped to hire people to write about a subject about which they have been so flagrantly wrong for so long, until proven otherwise we should assume that the motives involved are dark, vile and salacious."

Q: Is Tom Nichols to driftglass as Pat Boone is to Little Richard?

A: MONEY

(I would also have accepted "A: Reactionary subversion" but it's really all the same thing, innit)

Brilliantly spelled out regardless.

bt1138 said...

"they have been so flagrantly wrong for so long, until proven otherwise we should assume that the motives involved are dark, vile and salacious."

---

That's the nail on the head. Tom here is not so stupid as he pretends to be; none of them are stupid, and they all know what it was, is and where it's going. They are all Captain Louis Renault and they are "Shocked Shocked I Tell You" about what's been going in the Casino. Some seemmore committed to the cause, some are clearly looking for a paycheck.

Lying on cue and making up new and/or false histories is the the glue the keeps the Q-Fox-OP rolling along. It's their superpower. It's what makes it faith-based - they can keep the rubes rolling with one dark prophecy after another of good vs evil (you know who is who, right?), and when the prophecies fail, new ones are crafted and it all starts over.

It's always just one more lifeboat as you know. They come in all shapes and sizes, and can hold one or two VIP's or can be made large enough to carry many.

I am modestly hopeful that Trump will end breaking them is some real ways in the long run - he really exposed so many of the internal inconsistencies. A lot of people may honestly finally be forced to admit that the Emperor has no clothes.