Monday, December 13, 2010
You Struck The Tsar!
When
It
Changes.
This is a metaphor.
There is a moment near the end of "Nicholas & Alexandra" when -- if you didn't know how the story ends -- you finally realize the Romanovs are truly doomed: the moment when a guard slaps the tsar (link here.)
The slap itself is nothing -- far worse violence has unfolded both on and off screen during most of the preceding 14-hour movie run-time -- but, like Rick's little nod to the band in "Casablanca", what it represents in terms of a radical change to the trajectory of the protagonists cannot be understated. During all that has gone before, the royal family and their retainers had been protected by an invisible shield which no one dared penetrate -- the accumulated weight of hundreds of years of political and religious mythos.
However much his circle of protection constricted and however much of his liberty and property was stripped, centuries of sermons and cossacks had flogged this fact into the Russian soul: if you screwed with the tsar, something Very Very Bad would happen. The royal family was all that stood between order and Universal chaos, so the least you could expect was that Almighty God would drop a bomb on your head.
Absolutely. Positively. Automatically.
Ah, but when a guard finally slaps the tsar...nothing happens.
And when no wrath from On High is forthcoming -- when the tsar is shown to be merely a man -- the last, thin protective shield around his family collapses. In that giant moment, the previously unthinkable became suddenly thinkable...and history -- at least as it was represented cinematically -- changed.
On the Left, I would argue that history just changed in an equally big way, although you can be forgiven if you didn't notice. In America, reporting on what Left actually thinks is virtually nonexistent due to the Left's long and intolerably embarrassing record of being right about almost every big issue to come down the pike for the last 30-40 years. Instead, all we hear about are the sinister antics and motives of the whatever is plopping off the assembly line at the Straw Man Factory today: for the brainwashed slugs on the Right, the Left is forever a fictional cabal of "committed Marxists" whose dark conspiracies are responsible for everything that has ever gone wrong since Eden; for the spineless pussies in the Center, the Left is a fictional bunch of "unreasonable fringe-types" against whom they have been trained to automatically heap gratuitous opprobrium every time the Right fucks them over again.
For, y'know, "balance".
The truth is, despite mainstream press attempts to sledgehammer this debate back into the same, suffocating Sister-Soulja-Base-versus-the-Reasonable-President straight-jacket (Bernie Sanders who?), this last bit of "hostage taking" over tax cuts for billionaires has changed things on the Left the same way that the Presidential election of 2004 changed things.
What happened this week was that the GOP finally dropped its last fig-leaf and with it, any pretense of a conscience.
In 2004, the Cheney Administration offered the imbeciles, cowards and bigots who despised this country enough to re-elect the worst president in American history an ample supply of flags and bibles and "Boot in their ass"-themed country music behind which they could hide when called upon to justify their truly spectacular desecration of every American value they purported to admire.
Granted the rationalizations that the Party of Personal Responsibility offered up were patently ridiculous, but as always they Right found that if they just backed their phony excuses up by screaming "Why do you hate America?!" loud enough, the sheer decibel level of their lies could blot out any reasonable attempt to rebut them.
This time, the Party of God has left them nothing. Not a shred of ideological camouflage. Not a single economic entrenching tool with which to dig themselves a plausible spider hole. Nothing.
And this is what changed. 2010 will go down as the year that the lies which have sustained the Right for 40 years finally got too ridiculous and top-heavy to be maintained, and the GOP just gave up pretending that it is anything other than a cesspit of thieves and fascists and lunatics.
And the media shrugged.
After two years of constant lying and intractable, public, reactionary opposition to everything in the name of nothing but clawing their way back to power over the corpse of the American Dream, 2010 became the year the Right got tired of half measures, pulled out a gun, jammed it right in the face of national security, the United States military, the poor, 9/11 first responders, the families of those blown to bits by BP, and the unemployed and shrieked "Gimme the money! "Gimme the money! Just gimme the fucking money!"
And the media smirked.
This was year the Right finally stepped its depravity fully and nakedly out of the cage and into the spotlight (video no longer available) sending the media and the White House scurrying away in a frenzied search for... cranky Liberal purity sluts to blame it on.
This was the year when the Right unapologetically reached out and slapped the American people hard and publicly across the mouth just because they fucking well could.
And nothing happened.
Nobody stood up and yelled "Liar!" during one of Boehner's speeches. No rallies featuring grifting mama grizzlies or people in funny hats packing assault rifles were held to denounce the GOP. None of the Very Serious People who are supposed to stand steadfastly on the side of the American people against such nakedly anti-American rapaciousness could rouse themselves to do a fucking thing but whine about what sanctimonious pricks Liberals are.
And the last, thin protective shield around the fantasy that we can coexist with the monsters on the Right and the cowards in the Center finally collapsed and died.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
-
To date, this is how the very few interactions I've had with Never Trumpers have gone, because I want to talk about the Befor...
-
“This maybe the year when we finally come face to face with ourselves; finally just lay back and say it—that we are really j...
19 comments:
The one thin reed they are using to justify tax cuts for the caviar class is "the wealthy need the cuts in order to create more jobs".
Yeah, that worked so well during the reign of Bush the Lesser, when the very same tax cuts were in place and the so-called recovery from recession was the weakest one in post-WWII history.
Perhaps if Obama and Clinton (since Obama handed him the podium last week) had said anything other than "give them the money," someone in the media might have noticed.
We on the left lack the bullhorn.
"...finally collapsed and died."
If a tree falls in the forest, and no one is there to hear it, does it make a sound?
I fear the event is unoticed by the public at large. We are too busy with the pitchforks and torches handed to us by our masters.
Maybe next time.
DG,
If we're lucky, a guy like this might come along. And the truth is, there is something terribly wrong with this country, isn't there? Cruelty and injustice, intolerance and oppression. And where once you had the freedom to object, to think and speak as you saw fit, you now have censors and systems of surveillance coercing your conformity and soliciting your submission.
I have a feeling we're entering the long coma that many others have been through in such places as Soviet Russia, Poland, East Germany and Czechoslovakia. No bullhorn (h/t Denny), no advocate (anyone expect Sanders to last much longer?), no public unity (except that I believe we are indeed unified in our terrified privacy). But a time where the truncheon is used in lieu of conversation, yet where words will always retain their power... because Words offer the means to meaning, and for those who will listen, the enunciation of truth.
Sadly, I remain doubtful our caped hero will arrive in a timely manner. Instead, we must suffer quietly, patiently, devising and using our own samzidat, our own committees of correspondence, to keep the dreams of America alive. As with truth, life and liberty will out. And that is what those with the truncheons fail to understand, time and time again.
Its going to get rougher, friend. But maybe one day we'll live to see the time when our side has "struck the Tsar."
Thanks for keeping that flickering flame alive for the rest of us. You remind us that that fairness, justice, and freedom are more than words, they are perspectives.
@RP: No Act Of Rebellion Is Wasted by Chris Hedges
As the existential horror gets worse, you get better. Keep shouting the truth DG.
Excellent commentary!
"In 2004, the Cheney Administration offered the imbeciles, cowards and bigots who despised this country enough to re-elect the worst president in American history an ample supply of flags and bibles and "Boot in their ass"-themed country music behind which they could hide when called upon to justify their truly spectacular desecration of every American value they purported to admire."
I loved that, I wish I could write like that. The Plutocracy is here, and it is solid. I am often perplexed that there isn't a left-center populist or charismatic leader that can make the case, and be heard, that it's all about the money. It's as plain as day, but most people don't get it. It's about the money. Everything... is about the money.
"And the media smirked."
Anon, if such a leader does emerge, what can s/he do when the Malefactors Of Great Wealth own all the means of mass communication?
The MOGW don't even need to kill or jail such people any longer. They can just ignore them into oblivion.
Indeed, MftI. That's the very reason the plutocrats are working so feverishly to kill the open Internet.
I love ya, Dg!
And you are sooooooo on target all the time.
And especially here.
Leading me to smile, smile, smile for the first time in a very long while.
No wonder no one in the major media wants to hire such a fine writer/reporter as you.
You expose the lot with every syllable.
They must quake in fear of ever having to be judged by you.
. . . spineless pussies in the Center, the Left is a fictional bunch of "unreasonable fringe-types" against whom they have been trained to automatically heap gratuitous opprobrium every time the Right fucks them over again.
For, y'know, "balance".
. . . What happened this week was that the GOP finally dropped its last fig-leaf and with it, any pretense of a conscience.
. . . Not a single economic entrenching tool with which to dig themselves a plausible spider hole. Nothing.
. . . 2010 will go down as the year that the lies which have sustained the Right for 40 years finally got too ridiculous and top-heavy to be maintained, and the GOP just gave up pretending that it is anything other than a cesspit of thieves and fascists and lunatics.
. . . public, reactionary opposition to everything in the name of nothing but clawing their way back to power over the corpse of the American Dream
. . . Right got tired of half measures, pulled out a gun, jammed it right in the face of national security, the United States military, the poor, 9/11 first responders, the families of those blown to bits by BP, and the unemployed and shrieked "Gimme the money! "Gimme the money! Just gimme the fucking money!"
. . . White House scurrying away in a frenzied search for... cranky Liberal purity sluts to blame it on.
. . . This was the year when the Right unapologetically reached out and slapped the American people hard and publicly across the mouth just because they fucking well could.
And nothing happened.
But the McDonald's where I hang out sometimes did get reaaaallllyyy quiet after that slap.
So, there's that.
Love ya,
S
P.S. I hope DFB and TFF are among the missing.
And the last, thin protective shield around the fantasy that we can coexist with the monsters on the Right and the cowards in the Center finally collapsed and died.
Ah, it seems we await a deus ex machina. Ain't gonna' happen.
Money talks and bullshit walks.
They got the money--we don't--end of story.
We have only the "moral injury" Tom Hayden alludes to.
Might be enough.
Might be.
Adapted from the Pearl Jam lyrics:
driftglass, driftglass, driftglass away.
The suitcoats say, 'There is money to be made.'
They get so damn excited, BUT I GUESS IT'S THEIR WAY.
My road it may be lonely just because it's not paved.
It's good for driftglass, driftglass away.
The suitcoats say, 'There is money to be made.'
They get so excited, nothing gets in their way
My road it may be lonely just because it's not paved.
It's good for driftglass, driftglass
driftglass, driftglass, driftglass, along.
I feel like going back there, but never for long.
I sometimes wonder if they know that I'm gone.
Never stop driftglass...
@Loveandlight: Thanks. I think this last election only confirms Hedges' POV and that article indeed was on my mind when I wrote my screed above.
Words. Words and example. Words, example and local good. In these times, I think that is the best we and our fellow thinkers going to be able to do. These and keeping alive the memory and promise of a better nation.
It will be a dark, lonely, suffering twilight. As Denny says, no Duex ex Machina is coming. No, the end of this new era only comes when the plutocracy collapses of its own weight. At the rate they are bailing, that collapse may not be too long in coming. Either way, it will be far too long for me.
Thanks again drifty and keep on scribing! And podcasting!
“Driftglass,” an impatient Mr. Obama interrupted him, “do people really talk like that?”
Damn right they do.
A petition to save the Open Internet.
Maybe signing this will help, maybe it won't, but it's not difficult and takes just a few measely minutes.
Loveandlight, thanks for that article on fighting the good (even if losing short-term) fight. Its a keeper.
Retired Patriot, I'm coming more and more to the conclusion that the only way out, for a return to a caring society, is for the corporate plutocracy to self-collapse from its own unbridled greed. Well, and hope it doesn't segue into fascism/dictatorship along the way. Either way, the non-rich will pay the price as well as (hopefully) the rich.
The US has been here before. the 1880s and 1890s saw corporations and the rich take control of the economy, the politicians, and the courts. The media (newspapers then) could bully pulpit the population into war. Many a parallel to what we're heading into. It took nearly 50 years for that implosion to finally occur, including many bank runs/panics, economic scares, violent strikes, one or two World Wars, and a couple of Roosevelts (and Obama ain't looking like a Roosevelt - Teddy nor Franklin).
Grapes of Wrath is my favorite book. Hell of a thing that I may have to relive it. I hope I live long enough to see this through to the other side.
Excellent comparison.
And on a more trivial but fun level, how cool is it for us Doctor Who geeks that the Tsar is played by Michael Jayston, AKA The Valeyard from Trial of a Time Lord, and Rasputin is played by Tom Baker, the fourth Doctor?
"Ah, but when a guard finally slaps the tsar...nothing happens."
Except for maybe 70 years of Communist oppression and atrocity.
Post a Comment