Monday, October 24, 2005

So we’re doing this now.


God damned body counts.

Well of course we are.

OK, anybody still think this isn’t Vietnam 2.0?

If so, kindly pick out favorite firearm (and I’m sure you have dozens), jam it down your windpipe ‘til the hammer tickles your uvula, and pull the trigger. Because you, Pooky, are just way, WAY too stupid to live and need to get the fuck off my planet with all deliberate speed.

Unfamiliar with the topic?

I’ll make it easy.

See if you can spot any basic difference between this story, ripped from today’s headlines, with emphasis added by me.

Enemy Body Counts Revived
U.S. Is Citing Tolls to Show Success in Iraq
By Bradley Graham
Washington Post Staff Writer
Monday, October 24, 2005

Eager to demonstrate success in Iraq, the U.S. military has abandoned its previous refusal to publicize enemy body counts and now cites such numbers periodically to show the impact of some counterinsurgency operations.

The revival of body counts, a practice discredited during the Vietnam War, has apparently come without formal guidance from the Pentagon's leadership. Military spokesmen in Washington and Baghdad said they knew of no written directive detailing the circumstances under which such figures should be released or the steps that should be taken to ensure accuracy.

Instead, they described an ad hoc process that has emerged over the past year, with authority to issue death tolls pushed out to the field and down to the level of division staffs.

...
[The} Oct. 16 statement reflected some of the pitfalls associated with releasing such statistics. The number was immediately challenged by witnesses, who said many of those killed were not insurgents but civilians, including women and children.

...
"Specific numbers are used to periodically provide context and help frame particular engagements," said Brig. Gen. Donald Alston, director of communications for the U.S. military command in Baghdad. He added, however, that there is no plan "to issue such numbers on a regular basis to score progress."

During the Vietnam War, enemy body counts became a regular feature in military statements intended to demonstrate progress. But the statistics ended up proving poor indicators of the war's course. Pressure on U.S. units to produce high death tolls led to inflated tallies, which tore at Pentagon credibility.

"In Vietnam, we were pursuing a strategy of attrition, so body counts became the measure of performance for military units," said Conrad C. Crane, director of the military history institute at the U.S. Army War College. "But the numbers got so wrapped up with career aspirations that they were sometimes falsified."

The Vietnam experience led U.S. commanders to shun issuing enemy death tallies in later conflicts, through the initial stages of the Iraq war. "We don't do body counts on other people," Defense Secretary Donald H. Rumsfeld said in November 2003, when asked on "Fox News Sunday" whether the number of enemy dead exceeded the U.S. toll.

That policy appeared to shift with the assault on the insurgent stronghold of Fallujah in November, an operation considered crucial at the time to denying safe havens to enemy fighters. U.S. military officials reported 1,200 to 1,600 enemy fighters killed, although reporters on the scene noted far fewer corpses were found by Marines after the fighting.

...
High-ranking commanders also have contributed to the trend. In January, Army Gen. George Casey, the top U.S. officer in Iraq, said U.S. and Iraqi forces had killed or captured 15,000 people last year. In May, Air Force Gen. Richard B. Myers, then-chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff, mentioned the killing of 250 of insurgent leader Abu Musab Zarqawi's "closest lieutenants" as evidence of progress in Iraq.

...
The release of such figures also can serve to boost the morale of U.S. forces and bolster confidence "that their plans and weapons work effectively," said Marine Lt. Col. David Lapan, spokesman for the 2nd Marine Expeditionary Force, which operates in western Iraq.

...
Still, defense specialists such as Crane cautioned that enemy body counts in Iraq and Afghanistan are prone to inaccuracy and are of questionable significance. The murky nature of the conflicts, they said, make it difficult to know at times who is an insurgent, a criminal or an innocent civilian.

"There still are problems in identifying who is who, just as there were in Vietnam," Crane said.


And this swatch of photo-realistic dialogue ripped from Stanley Kubrick’s Vietnam masterpiece, “Full Metal Jacket.”

LOCKHART
And, Joker ... where's the weenie?

JOKER
Sir!

LOCKHART
The Kill, JOKER. The kill. I mean, all that fire,
the grunts must've hit something.

JOKER
Didn't see 'em.

LOCKHART
Joker, I've told you, we run two basic stories
here. Grunts who give half their pay to buy gooks
toothbrushes and deodorants — Winning of Hearts and
Minds--okay? And combat action that results in a
kill--Winning the War.

Now you must have seen blood trails ... drag marks?

JOKER
It was raining, sir.

LOCKHART
Well, that's why God passed the law of probability.
Now rewrite it and give it a happy ending--say, uh,
one kill. Make it a sapper or an officer. Which?

JOKER
Whichever you say.


Anybody remember how that scene ends? The “weenie”? The fucking cherry on top?

LOCKHART
Grunts like reading about dead officers.

JOKER
Okay, an officer. How about a general?

Or how about yet another “Number Two Man” in the AQ network that no one had heard of before his teeth had been pulled out of the rubble and matched with a name.

If you still can’t see the terrible symmetry and where it is leading us, lay down where you are, draw a chalk outline around yourself and wait for the M.E.

Because you are already as one with the dead.

28 comments:

jurassicpork said...

Good on them. Then we'll be free to publicize how many Iraqi women and children and non-combatants that our forces have killed, starting with that wedding party that killed 40 happy people.

I don't think that the Madministration would have a problem with that, do you? After all, it's not as if they go for double standards or anything, right?

Neil Shakespeare said...

The old joke during the Vietnam Era, at least according to a vet friend of mine, about how they arrived at the body count:

"You take the average number of mosquitos on a GI's ass and divide by the number of bullets shot."

Anonymous said...

How ironic that you should post this today--tomorrow, Matthew Modine's "Full Metal Jacket Diary" is released.

I'm sure he'd thank you for the free publicity if he knew.

Anonymous said...

Biting work, old boy. Glad to see the cobwebs have cleared.

Anonymous said...

In Biggio??????????.

Anonymous said...

US military says that 2000 deaths is an 'artificial mark' and should be ignored.

The Pentagon must go on the 'millenium' calendar... the important death count doesn't start until 2001.

Ha ha ha ha ha ah.....

jurassicpork said...

And yet...and yet, get this: ”2000 is not a milestone.”

So, numbers only count when you're talking about the other casualties, then? Ahhhh, I see, now.

Anonymous said...

Sick puppy GWB is.........I'LL SAY.

Unknown said...

Man there is alot of comment spam I have noticed. Is there any way to remove it from the blogs?

Anonymous said...

I started a small blog from some pictures I had taken in Nam. Some of them are about agent orange vietnam war and similar subjects. I went to your blog to get ideas of how others did theirs. Nice job ! ---Jack---

Anonymous said...

Remercie encore de l'occasion de partager.Toodle-oo, Mohammed wedding anniversary gifts

Anonymous said...

Great blog. In case you care to know, I was searching for what foods can i eat on an atkins diet and your blog came up. I am glad I found it though.

Very nice.

Anonymous said...

This is a very nice site. I was out looking for "paul adkins cullman al" and found your blog in the process.

Best of luck.

Anonymous said...

I was looking for information on Alvidar for weight loss, came across your blog...good info, you might find mine of interest over active thyroid,http://www.mailbag.ws/alvidar.htm

Anonymous said...

Bloggin for info on weight loss, specifcally about Alvidar came across your blog...good info, you might find mine of interest ##keyword ##http://www.mailbag.ws/alvidar.htm hyperthyroidism,

Anonymous said...

Although I don't think you can use fasting as a diet or weight loss program, I do feel that it can be a great start to a proper weight loss diet and exercise program. I think it is definitely something that everyone should do at least once a year.
Link to this site. summer weight loss camp kid
http://better-weightloss.info

Anonymous said...

Although I don't think you can use fasting as a diet or weight loss program, I do feel that it can be a great start to a proper weight loss diet and exercise program. I think it is definitely something that everyone should do at least once a year.
Link to this site. weight loss using hypnosis
http://better-weightloss.info

Anonymous said...

Lose Weight Now. Fasting, when done peoperly, can be a basoc part of a solid weight loss plan. If done correctly it can ne a great start to your new way of life.
Link to this site. vegetarian weight loss diet plan
http://better-weightloss.info

Anonymous said...

This is an excellent site, is it all your own doing. I have just added you to my firm favourites and will come back again soon. Maybe you will find my blog interesting. smoking cessation advice

Anonymous said...

Just checking out blogs and thought I would stop and read yours since we have some of the same interests and ideas. Some of the ideas are a little much and some are right on. I am glad I stopped by just to say hi I hope you don't mind. Some people consider it spam ( I DON'T ) but if you don't want people to post why do they leave it open for the world to see. I have some great wedding information and articles available for free around 2000 savings ideas so stop on in if you want... I also have some of the most informative sites on yoga and baby gifts and baby showers. Hope you enjoy Thank you for your time.lesbian wedding vows

lesbian wedding vows

Anonymous said...

I really liked your info today. Continue writing. Time to scoot.

Anonymous said...

Really enjoyed your comments. I have personal development site I think you might enjoy.

Anonymous said...

site hoodia-product.info I have found a proven way anyone can lose weight within a week, without any crazy dieting. This product is a no-nonsense solution for obesity. People just like you are losing weight right now! Stop worrying about being overweight, Start living your life the way YOU want to! - Please visit site hoodia-product.info

Anonymous said...

I've been blogging all day,and came across yours.. looking good, just looking for ideas for my own, your the 50th blog today,

Thank,
Pat
diet green pill tea

Anonymous said...

Nice blog you have. Here's a great site about self-hypnosis

Anonymous said...

I have been looking for love dating advice for teen sites such as http://single-dating-service.org and I found this blog. It's really interesting.

Anonymous said...

diet program One of the most important tips for weight loss is to know when to have your last meal. Learn more. Please visit diet program

Anonymous said...

Enjoyed the posts. low calorie diet Please feel free to check out my diet blog for diet tips and advice. Please visit low calorie diet