From Newsweek:
Only in AmericaPlease understand, it’s Not a Racial Thing.
Barack Obama is a Niebuhr-reading ESPN watcher. The origins of his troubles with the 'other' tag.
Evan Thomas, Holly Bailey and Richard Wolffe
…
Following Hillary Clinton's lead, the McCain team sees an opportunity to paint Obama as an out-of-touch elitist, a Harvard toff who nibbles daintily at designer salads while the working man, worried about layoffs at the plant, belts another shot. Though the McCain advisers are divided about who would make the more beatable candidate in November, they see a chance to peel off Reagan Democrats—older working-class voters—in key swing states of the rust belt if Obama is the Democratic nominee. While McCain himself is publicly neutral on which Democrat he would prefer to oppose, in recent weeks he has noticeably gone easier on Clinton than Obama, perhaps out of hopes of winning over some of her working-class base.
…
But in Obama's failure to lock up the nomination, there may be something more disturbing going on as well.
Americans do not like to talk about class, and they want to believe racism is a thing of the past. Theodore and Franklin Roosevelt, paragons of the people, were decidedly upper class in background, style and habit, and no one seemed to mind (except some other members of the upper class, who regarded the Roosevelts as "traitors" for wanting to tax and regulate the rich). JFK and Ronald Reagan were princely in their own ways (of Camelot and Hollywood) and yet could touch the hearts of common men and women.
…
The most successful presidents have always been open and hopeful, sunny and optimistic about the promise of American equality and opportunity. But there has long been a dark side to democratic politics, a willingness to play on prejudice, to get men and women to vote their fears and not their hopes. Those prejudices fade and seem to die down, but they never quite go away. They remain embers for cunning political operatives to fan into flames.
An exit poll of Pennsylvania voters included a chilling number that makes one wonder if Americans, or at least some groups in some parts of America, are ready to elect a black president. In the poll, 12 percent of whites said that race was a factor in deciding their votes. …In the NEWSWEEK Poll, more than half the voters said they think "most" (12 percent) or "some" (41 percent) of the voters will "have reservations about voting for a black candidate that they are not willing to express." In close elections, decided on the margins, it is discouraging to think that a small minority of racists could make the difference.
What is just weird is this: how can it be that a black man running for president is accused of being too elitist? For the first century of the nation's existence, blacks were kept in chains. For the next century, they were sent to the back of the bus and kept away from whites-only lunch counters and restrooms throughout the South—much less allowed to join the white elite in their schools and clubs and prestigious institutions. Then, starting in the 1960s, American society began to make a concerted effort to open up those doors. Barack Obama is not so much the beneficiary of that effort as the proof that blacks can make it on their own, if given the chance. He was, despite a modest upbringing, elected editor of the Harvard Law Review, a position at the very tip of the meritocratic ziggurat.
Yet to pockets of America, he still seems to be the "other." He seems a little strange, exotic; those cracked e-mails whispering about his middle name (Hussein) and declaring, fictitiously, that he is a Muslim who insisted on being sworn into office on the Qur'an rather than the Bible, keep buzzing around the Internet. To some, his manner is haughty; he is a bit of an egghead, one of those pointy-headed intellectuals whom George W. Bush liked to ridicule as a Deke brother at Yale and even later as president of the United States (and, long before him, demagogues like the anti-Semitic right-wing radio priest of the 1940s, Father Charles Coughlin; Red-baiter Sen. Joe McCarthy of Wisconsin, and race-baiter Gov. George Wallace of Alabama).
Demagoguing, even in the subtle ways enabled by new media, can have an impact over time. In the NEWSWEEK Poll, 13 percent reported that Obama is Muslim. NEWSWEEK reporters on the campaign trail could hear the wariness, even fearfulness, of voters as they spoke about Obama.
…
It’s not, not, not. We double-Blue-Dog-swear it's not.
It’s just that every Obama supporter is completely delusional.
So full of hate.
It’s like they’re so hypnotized or deranged they can’t even see how dangerous and unelectable their candidate is.
Take for example all this talk about “hope” this and “hope” that. We have real problems in this county! We’re at war for goodness sakes, and our economy is in real trouble, and we do not need some exotic Ivy-league elitist snob
who doesn’t understand our problems running our country.
We just need someone
more like us.
And these young people he’s bringing in?
Just kids, really.
No idea how the real world works, and what can you say except to agree with Bill Clinton that it's easy to be bamboozled by a slick operator with a lot of fine words when you are young and foolish.
No, we really need someone
a little more like us.
And he comes out of “Chicago”, with all of that scary, big city machine politics they have there.
So you know that means he was corrupt, even if we can't come up with some fancy lawyer "proof".
You just know that while he claims he was (allegedly) a "community organizer", he was probably really one of those back-room, city fixer pols.
Instead of someone
more like us.
Plus we hear he has some kinda shady dealings with the mob maybe. Some Arab named “Rezko”. We don’t know all the details, but there are rumors, and "Where There's Smoke, There's Fire" we say.
Like we said, it’s not a racial thing.
It’s just that he is obviously con artist with a lot of shady friends, and we don’t need that in the White House.
We need someone
more like us.
And can you believe that church he goes to?
All of those bizarre rituals? And the weird music they play? The language they use? And that they obviously hated America so much they felt they had to go set up their own, separate church?
It just chills the blood to think that someone who follows those crazy teachings would be in charge of our country!
Sure his followers says that one, 30-second snip taken out of context and from a 40-year-ministry is not a fair way to judge, but as we have already proven with iron logic, they are all obviously delusional.
And we say, why take that chance?
And, sure, he says his pastor won’t be giving him Secret Orders – maybe even Secret Foreign Orders! -- but you just never know with those people and their alien religion.
Like we said, it’s not a racial thing at all, so quit saying that has anything to do with anything!
If only he wasn’t some fringe church whacko.
Sigh.
If only he was
more like us.
And he consorts with radicals. 60s radicals. Did you know that?
And his resume is too thin.
And don’t even get us started on the weird, highfalutin way he talks.
So, just to be crystal clear, this has nothing to do with the color of his skin.
No, no, no!
It is simply that this Party -- especially during a time of crisis -- would never, ever embrace some hope-peddler who reeks of
Ivy-league elitism, suspect religion and inexperience.
So quit harping on the racial thing.
It's obviously not a racial thing.
It's obvious that the millions of people who voted for him are all insane, and that Barack Obama is simply
not one of us.
25 comments:
Jewel bright and beautifully done.
Encapsulating my hopes... and fears.
But ya know... anyone who scares the Powers Who Hope to Hang On that much...
is doing SOMETHING right.
Because Obama is failing to seize the moment and do what is necessary to take charge, you blame everyone but Obama. It appears you've made a bad choice with Obama, going with him before he had been properly vetted. Not so bad that you've done it, but Moveon and Dean doing it have divided the party, with potentially significantly results.
There's no elitism among the hard core Obamacans. Ask 'em and they'll tell you there is nothing special about them, it's just that morally speaking everyone else dwells in the sewers.
What was that that Barack Obama said about the Grand Kleagle Bill Clinton? "I'm a big believer in reconciliation and redemption." That' great news Bill, "The One" says you can be redeemed.
Wow, drifty. That's some work there. Just wow!
And, lookee there. You've got some contrarians (being nice here) of your very own now. You've arrived. Heh.
In all the wild oscillations of hyperbole that shoot through this interminable hoopla like rancid veins of fat in a spoiled rump roast - Is this '68 redux? Or '72? Is candidate Obama white enough? Black enough? McCain - heroic survivor or spoiled brat receiving an almost O.Henryesque comeuppance? on and numbingly on...When, at last, will the meter pin itself and break into glittering shards of finite wisdom?
Having lived through '68, and viscerally felt the ripping of RFK away from me, us, our future, I sure as hell hope its not a redux, though I can understand why you might draw the parallel. '72 didn't have the economic cluster-F*ck that this year's cycle does - so even if there seems to be similar sized and configured holes in the BHOalition, the pain everyone is starting to feel makes analogy to McGovern's run something of a bad fit.
The principal exaggerating factor seems to be the presence of the skeevy Goebbelsization of American Media - which seems intent on focusing our attention on haircuts and harlots, instead of real issues which oughta comprise the basis for our votes.
once in the darkest boonies of the central highlands of vietnam the AFRTS network didn't vet a newsreel closely enough.
the guys in my unit got to hear bobby kennedy telling LBJ
I won't cut my hair until we are out of Viet Nam.
we stood. we. cheered.
Wow. I loved that, Driftglass. Long-form poetry w/ pictures. Simply wonderful.
Jeez, drifty. I think you struck a nerve there. A couple of your comments are a little sandy.
As to "elitist", they are most certainly trying to change the definition. Truly it is becoming a new euphemism. It now means "the other", and in this case, I think we all know what that means.
Elitistpleeze.
Anybody who can use the word elitist to describe Obama and differentiate him from former-First-Lady-who-has-made-$100-million-plus-these-last-few-years-Clinton and I-think-I'll-just-hop-in-my-wife's-corporate-jet,-damn-the-campaign-reform-law-with-my-name-on-it-McCain seriously deserves an Inigo Montoya cock of the head and a hearty "You keep using that word. I do not think it means what you think it means."
Sigh. One has to wonder now and then, just where this country would be today if we had gotten Bobby instead of Tricky Dick.
Only one thing to say:
Wow!
Sigh. One has to wonder now and then, just where this country would be today if we had gotten Bobby instead of Tricky Dick.
Lawdy, I don't have to wonder at all. The answer is a sh*tload better place than we are right now. And Tricky woulda passed away at a microphone, spewing B1 Bob isms to his skeevy cadre of car salesmen and Old Spice aficianados. Kind of a lower budget Falafelman.
And, "minstrelboy" thanks for sharing that great RFK anecdote, too.
One of the defining characteristics of the current administration has been to define its opposition in terms of the very things it is itself doing (treason, un-Americanism, cowardice, etc.). Did you expect them to change their playbook that quickly?
To quote Miles Davis, Your a motherfucker...
I came back again and again over the last few days looking for new content- never expecting to have this bit of pure art awaiting. Every time you exceed my expectations, even my ideas, about what you might dream up next. Kudos.
*bows*
"gabba gabba we accept ya' we accept ya' one of us..."
Justme writes:
****************
Jeez, drifty. I think you struck a nerve there. A couple of your comments are a little sandy.
As to "elitist", they are most certainly trying to change the definition. Truly it is becoming a new euphemism. It now means "the other", and in this case, I think we all know what that means.
*****************
You really can't help yourself can you?
Oh, and the size of someone's bank account does not determine whether or not they are elitist. But trying to explain that to you would be a waste of bandwidth.
Smug on Justme.
Nothing like Harvard-grad Evan Thomas and Oxford-grad Richard Wolffe explainging to America why Obama isn't a regular guy.
1) Obama's "arugula" comment was about how upscale sales of commodities like arugula suggest that farmers can be paid a higher commodity price for their production.
2) Reinhold Niebur, a person Wolffe and Thomas choose as an example because he has a funny foreign name and because they have read him themselves at Oxford and Harvard, is so odd and non-regular that he actually introduced regular guy John F. Kennedy at a Kennedy event. So this crazy weird sounding Niebur guy turns out to have been courted by John F. Kennedy IN THE FLESH, not a dusty old book. And foreign sounding Reinhold Neibur was borne in Wright City, Missouri.
http://speakingoffaith.publicradio.org/programs/niebuhr-rediscovered/timeline.shtml
3) On a personal note I once shared a beer in a bar in Maine with a fisherman who fished for sea urchins. He was met at the dock by Japanese buyers who graded and paid a price on the spot so that the fresh urchin could be flown across to globe to Japan where wealthy businessmen would eat the urchin in fancy bars. Understanding this didn't make the guy a swell. I mention this because it's an exact analog of the story Obama told to the farmers in Iowa. My guy smelled like fish and beer and had a scruffy gray beard. Obama, not so much. But they have the same intuitive understanding of the economy that allows "regular folks" not only to survive but thrive. I wouldn't expect swells like Evan Thomas and Richard Wolffe to understand any of this. They are too busy pretending to paint faux noble portraits of working class Joes as if average Americans are putting on airs if they admire John Kennedy and John Glenn instead of John Daly.
PS - Newsweek reporter Holly Bailey went to Oklahoma. If she's responsible for most of the content, it was still crap. Go Sooners!
PPS - I can't wait for the cover story in Newsweek about John McCain serving couscous at a barbeque for his press friends. Oh wait that will never happen because the press is filled with cliquey douchebags.
CMike said...
and I reply,
You keep using that word. I do not think it means what you think it means.
Mike, you ignorant, misguided slut.
From the OED, emphasis mine.
[f. élite n.3 + -ism.]
Advocacy of or reliance on the leadership and dominance of an élite (in a society, or in any body or class of persons). Hence é"litist n. and a.
Jeez, Mikey, which candidate again was the DLC tool, shilling for the chosen few, and which one was funding mostly through hundreds of thousands of small dollar donations? Don't answer too fast, now.
Hillary's entire platform has been one giant paean to elitism from the get go. The very idea that she is somehow more qualified to run the country because she has been part of the ruling elite already has been the central tenet of her campaign. It's all she's got. To try to brand anybody else as elitist to distinguish them from Hillary is disingenuous at best.
I won't even go into son-of-a-son-of-an-Admiral McCain.
Maybe if you rinsed off before you got in the car, it wouldn't be so gritty when you walk, and you'd be in a better mood.
Justme, you really think cmike is one of us?? He's a MeCainiac troll and an asshole besides.\\Pablo
Justme wrote:
******************
Anybody who can use the word elitist to describe Obama and differentiate him from former-First-Lady-who-has-made-$100-million-plus-these-last-few-years-Clinton and I-think-I'll-just-hop-in-my-wife's-corporate-jet,-damn-the-campaign-reform-law-with-my-name-on-it-McCain seriously deserves an Inigo Montoya cock of the head and a hearty "You keep using that word. I do not think it means what you think it means."
******************
Challenged, Justme whips out the OED. You're getting closer fella but you won't want to be comparing the demographic make up of Sen. Obama supporters and Sen. Clinton's to prove who's an elitist.
Comparing O'Bummer and RFK.
(36-year-voting democrat makes vomiting sounds into trashcan)
the reason we, yes we, lost in 2000 and 2004 is because the nominees didn't stand up for themselves and grow a pair.
Nor will either of the two mini-me's currently flogging each other to death for the right to lose the election again.
O'B, Hellary, and McSwine are the lowest crud of the barrel imaginable, all of them. The fucking world is going down... i want to hear someone suggest do something about besides pander and play valedictorian. Hope? What the fuck does that mean in 2008? i hope McSwine will drop dead of cancer before November but that doesn't mean it will happen.
Yeah, this is really progressive guys. Top-shelf excuse making.
Nobody does it better.
Shows to go you that people who've believed lies for so long would rather go on believing than see the truth.
You nailed, it, Driftglass. Signed. Sealed. Deeeelivered.
Thank you.
What is also great to see on this blog what I been reading for years is that Driftglass has attracted his own stable of wing-nut trolls. (See op. cit. cmike and jimbo)
But better -- others on the board are takin' 'em down!!! bwaaaaaaaaa
Thanx, justme, for the Inigo Montoya refresher. No, he don't know what that word means. (Stage Direction: Said like Ricky Ricardo)
Thanx, minstrel boy, for the story on what happens when Armed Forces Censors don't do their jobs. Ohmygosh. That long-hair porn slipped into the jungles of 'Nam?
And, Driftglass, I appreciated your leitmotif (elitist enuf for yuh?) about how it is all abso-tutely-posi-definitely NOT Racism.
I have older women friends trying to pry me off my switch to Obama with back-handed comments: Look at Hillary's wonderful health care plan. And, no, it has nothing to do with BO being "a darkie." (Sorry ... direct quote) It's just that we NEED a woman president.
When I say: "Does that mean we need any old 'uterie' instead of a 'darkie'"? I get some very colorful words in reply. Oooooo.
The sad reality is that some people won't vote for Obama because he's Black. Just like some people won't vote for Hillary because she's a woman. Racism and sexism are still very much alive in this country, and I'm not sure we can eviscerate them before November.
As someone who supported RFK, I would certainly like to know how different the world might be today had he been elected president.
BAC
Catching up here - great post, Driftglass.
I'm hoping we can get beyond these attitudes. For some reason Obama seems to have the ability to keep letting these accusations slip off of him. Even the Wright fiasco hasn't stuck - so far. Fingers crossed.
Post a Comment