Long ago, for safekeeping, the soul of True Conservatism was cut up into Seven
Horcruxes. These are Conservatism's foundational axioms which, up until
a minute ago, pretty much every Republican agreed with -- both the 98% of the
party that lined up behind Trump, and the 2% who were shocked! shocked that
the 98% lined up behind Trump.
And every time one of these horcruxes is destroyed -- either by decay and
disuse, or by actually being enacted, after which that "shocked!shocked!" 2%
get shocked all over again by discovering that, in real life, their dearest
Conservative masturbatory fantasy was actually horrifying -- True Conservatism
gasps a little more loudly and dies a little bit more.
First Horcrux: Deficits are evil and can only be reduced by
massive cuts to social programs, which is legit because poverty is caused by
moral deficiency and the poor being kept helpless on the Commie Liberal
"plantation".
Second Horcrux: Massive tax cuts/reregulation/the "free
market"/private charities will solve all problems, including any disruptions
cause by massive cuts to social programs.
Third Horcrux: Racism isn't real. And even if it is,
Democrats [Did you know They Founded!! The!! Klan!! Huh!! Huh!! Didja know
that!!!] -- are the real racists.
Fourth Horcrux: Abortion is murder and repealing Roe v. Wade is a moral
imperative. Pretty much self-explanatory and self-evident. But
just for fun, hey, guess who wrote this?
"The fact is, the entire country is trapped. Harry Blackmun and his
colleagues suppressed that democratic abortion debate the nation needs to
have. The poisons have been building ever since. You can complain about
the incivility of politics, but you can't stop the escalation of conflict
in the middle. You have to kill it at the root. Unless Roe v. Wade is
overturned, politics will never get better. "
Yeah, that was Conservative thought leader
David Brooks in April of 2005.
Fifth Horcrux: An armed society is a polite society, but
gun-grabbing commie Dems want to take everyone's guns away and leave us all
defenseless.
As mass shooting have become daily events in the United States, even some of
the most, it seems to be slowly dawning on a number of True Conservatives
that, just maybe a country that has a wingnut media which pumps apocalyptic
rage and paranoia toxins into its audience 24/7 shouldn't also be a country
that is drowning in guns and open-carry/zero-training/stand-your-ground laws.
Sixth Horcrux: Packing the courts with Federalist Society killbots
by whatever means necessary is completely legitimate in the fight against
Liberal commies.
Via the Savior of the Republic, Rick Wilson:
See also, "Justice Sunday" above.
Seventh Horcrux: All of the above is necessary because
Liberals/Democrats are terrorist loving, Murrica hating weaklings who want to
turn us into Soviet Russia!
If you doubt that simply consult the totality of Conservative media -- from
the Limbaugh sewers to the National Review salons -- going back to Before the
Time of Agnew. All of it -- every paragraph, every sentence, every
comma and period -- all of it is animated by fear mongering,
barely concealed racism and a seething contempt for you and me and everything
we hold dear.
Here are a few excerpts from one speech by dead Rush Limbaugh, delivered at
CPAC barely one month after Barack Obama was inaugurated in 2009. His
"Of course I want Obama to fail" speech:
I am safe from any liberal attack, in public, because they would be
afraid of offending Stalin...
I sometimes wonder if liberalism is not just a psychosis or a psychology,
not an ideology...
I have learned how to tweak liberals everywhere. I do it instinctively
now. Tweak them in the media. And no reason to be afraid of these people.
Why in the world would you be afraid of the deranged? ...
President Obama with the communications skills, you know he could wipe
out the Republican Party. He can wipe out the Republican Party if he would
inspire this country to be the best it could be, but we don't have to
worry about that because that's not what he wants. He wants people in
fear, angst and crisis, fearing the worst each and every day because that
clears the decks for President Obama and his pals to come in with the
answers, which are abject failures, historically shown and
demonstrated...
That the Democrats and Obama are asking you to feel better simply on the
basis that they're going to get revenge for you, but your life isn't going
to improve, somebody else's is just going to be destroyed and they want
you to be happy over that. That's sick...
And beware of those different factions who seek as part of their attempt
to redefine conservatism, as making sure the liberals like us, making sure
that the media likes us. They never will, as long as we remain
conservatives. They can't possibly like us; they're our enemy...
This is the sewage of raw rage and paranoia that Conserative media scum --
including all of your favorite Never Trumpers -- spent decades pumping into
the eager, thirsty veins of their reader, listeners and views. This was their
native language. Their mother tongue.
And the all-powerful, all-occasion magic spell backstopping all seven
horcruxes has been this Conservative fail-safe: If you ever find
yourself caught in a lie you can't deny, remember,
Both Sides Do It (and Democrats are always worse.)
Soooo...
...if we take a look at the current condition of these seven pillars of
Conservatism, what can we learn about the present state of the Conservative
soul?
1. Deficits? Dead. The canard of "fiscal
conservatism" has gotten stomped near-to-death by every successive
Republican administration since Reagan. And now, however hard Kevin
McCarthy tries to reanimate that corpse, and however energetically our
Conservative Never Trump "allies" try to blow on those embers...there are no
embers. The Trump years have proven what Liberal have said all
along: Republicans never gave a damn about deficits.
2. Don't worry about massive cuts to social programs because, uh, tax
cuts! And, uh, deregulation!
Dead. This has never been true, and once Dark Brandon got the entire
Republican party on their feet, cheering for never cutting Medicare and Social
Security, from hundreds of miles away, high atop the Fox News tower, once
could almost hear the agonizing cries of Paul Ryan's granny-killin' soul leave
his body.
3. Racism isn't real/Democrats are the real racists. Dead. If you're a youngling you may not remember that, even though
Nixon opened the front door and rolled out the red carpet for the bigots in
the 1960s, Republicans continued to "LaLaLaICannotHearYou" the subject of
their party's built-in racism until about five minutes ago. As I have
written many times places, the average Republican comes off like they
have a PhD in American civil rights, but only from history from the 1850s
until around 1964.
Then their knowledge gets terribly murky and uncertain.
They'll recount the story of Republican Abraham Lincoln freeing the slaves as
if they, personally, had commanded the Union troops on Little Round Top,
instead of being the goons who weep every time a Confederate traitor flag was
pulled down, and rage every time a statue commemorating a Confederate traitor
was removed.
They'll lean hard on the puffed up fairy tale of Bill Buckley drive the
Birchers out of the Conservative movement when, in fact, he very much did not.
Debunking a Longstanding Myth About William F. Buckley
The popular notion that the National Review founder expelled the fringe from
the conservative movement is wrong.
And they'll swear they've never even heard of Lee Atwater.
One of the last high-profile defeats for a Very Serious Conservative Public
Intellectual in this dumb argument was back in 2007, after the
publication of The Conscience of a Liberal in 2007 by New York Times columnist, economist and Nobel laureate Paul Krugman. In his
book, Krugman recounts the details of Ronald Reagan's infamous 1980 Philadelphia, Mississippi campaign speech. Which caused his fellow New York Times columnist and GOP-apologist,
David Brooks, to go absolutely ballistic, except due to longstanding NYT
tradition, he was not allowed to cite his colleague Krugman by name, so his
column was an 800-word rant against the "slur" and "calumny" of someone,
somewhere against Reagan's sainted personage.
Then pretty much the entire internet, from the high-born to your's truly, very publicly sawed Brooks' ass off and served it to him on the good
china. After that, Brooks was marginally more circumspect,
limiting his columns to his jog-by of a Teabagger Rally happening near a black
family picnic and since no one was punching anyone, it was obvious to
Brooks that the Tea Party wasn't racist.
And there was
Brooks in 2009, cocking his ear at the deafening, racist primal scream of a Republican
party reacting to the election of Barack Obama, shrugging, and swearing he can't
hear a thing:
Well, I don’t have a machine for peering into the souls of Obama’s critics,
so I can’t measure how much racism is in there. But my impression is that
race is largely beside the point.
I wrote a whole long thing about the subject here ("David Brooks Doesn't Know When To Sit Quietly And Say Nothing") if you're interested.
The GOP went so far as to hire a black guy named Michael Steele to front for
their racist party for a few years. His job was basically to give
someone the bigots in the party could point at and say "See! We've got a
black!" as their party's seething racism became harder and harder to ignore.
Trump killed that horcrux dead, and ever since useful idiots and
sock-puppets-for-hire like Brooks and Steele have been explaining how all of
this came as a complete surprise to them, that no one coulda seen any of this
coming, and so forth. And let's not forget Tucker Carlson's many
recent and invaluable contributions to the subject:
The Tucker Carlson Text That “Set Off a Panic” at Fox: “It’s Not How
White Men Fight”
The New York Times revealed the message that so worried executives that it
precipitated the shock exit of the anchor.
A racially charged and bloodthirsty text sent by Tucker Carlson about the
assault of a protestor by Trump supporters was reportedly a key factor
that precipitated the anchor’s shock exit from Fox News last week...
4. Abortion is murder and repealing Roe v. Wade is a moral
imperative. Dead. Because Brooks (see above) has finally gotten his
wish: Roe has been struck down and millions of American women have been
stripped of a right they had assumed to be inviolate. Does anyone in
their right mind think this has made our politics...
From the AP:
DeSantis signs Florida GOP’s 6-week abortion ban into law
From Politico:
North Dakota governor signs 6-week abortion ban into law
It takes effect immediately.
From CNBC:
Abortion pill mifepristone is banned or restricted in some states
despite Supreme Court ruling
From Forbes:
Idaho Becomes First State To Restrict Interstate Travel For Abortion
...better?
And how is overturning Roe working out for the party that spent 50 years
trying to overturn Roe?
From the Washington Post:
Abortion divides 2024 candidates and confounds many within the GOP
From ABC News:
Republicans will 'lose huge' without finding 'middle ground' on abortion,
[Republican] Nancy Mace says
Hey dumbass, Roe was the middle ground.
5. Guns, Guns, Guns. Dead. Slaughtered over and
over again in that endless fusillade of AR-15 bullets that has become the
background music of American life. As mass shooting have become
daily events, it seems to be slowly dawning on a number of True Conservatives
that, just maybe, a country that has a wingnut media which pumps apocalyptic
rage and paranoia toxins into its audience 24/7 shouldn't also be a country
that is drowning in guns and open-carry/zero-training/stand-your-ground laws.
6. Pack those courts, and damn the cost! Dead. Even
as the radical decisions that Federalist-rotted courts at all levels has all
but killed the
public's faith in the competence...
Poll: Two-Thirds of Americans Don’t Have Confidence in Supreme Court
The drop in confidence comes as the Supreme Court debates the future of the
abortion pill.
...and
integrity of the judicial system...
The Supreme Court Is Lawless
Join us in an urgent project to track the dangerous ideas and decisions
of this activist court.
...the
open and shameless corruption...
The real reason for the Supreme Court’s corruption crisis
Who watches the philosopher kings with lifetime appointments?
...and
petty derangements...
Rage-filled Samuel Alito Baffled [That] His Fairness is Being
Questioned.
You will respect my authority, Justice insists.
...of the most conservative judges on the highest court in the land has driven
the final nails into its coffin.
So...with six of the seven True Conservative horcruxes stripped
away and destroyed either by the indifference of the GOP base or by the
catastrophes created by True Conservatives actually getting their dearest
wishes granted, what, at last, is left to sustain the rapidly disintegrating
True Conservative soul?
Just two things. Their hardwired sense of moral superiority/contempt for
dirty Liberals like you and me. And, of course, the all-powerful,
all-occasion conjure words that keep this last, mingy fragment of their soul
from turning to ash: Both Sides Do It (and Democrats are always worse.)
And if True Conservatism had just wandered off into the woods and disappeared
with only these two outrageous lies to keep then warm, I wouldn't have
cared. But they didn't exit the stage did they? Instead, they were
allowed to take over the stage. These failures and outcasts and authors
of our present miseries were, instead, allowed to fucking
colonize every corner of non-Fox/non-Newsmax media.
And everywhere they took root their message has been the same:
Sure Trump is a monster.
And obviously our republic is in danger from my
recently-former party.
But surely it must be equally obvious to all
normal, sensible Americans that only viable way out of this
mess is a Center-Left/Center-Right coalition of Sensible Centrists.
Because, as I'm sure we can all agree, the excesses on the crazy, zealot
Left are very nearly as dangerous as the excesses on the crazy, zealot
Right.
Because, as we all know, Both Sides Do It.
Except, of course...
Both Sides Don't